[Consumer study] What are consumer’s favorite mustard brands?

In this study, we wanted to find out what the favorite mustard brands of U.S. consumers are. But don’t just tell us, show us what brand is actually in your fridge.

favorite mustard brand

The methodology

In a few hours, we completed the study of 100 respondents through Voxpopme’s Influence market research online community (MROC) of on-demand consumers.

The platform neatly packaged the results in one dashboard.

favorite mustard brands summary


We asked consumers that like to eat mustard with their meals:

  • What is your favorite mustard brand?
  • Show us on camera which mustard brands you have at home.
  • Why is it your favorite brand, and what makes it so special compared to other brands?

Read next: Not sure what to ask? Check out Voxpopme’s tried and tested open-ended questions for video research.

The results

To sum it all up, we create a  quick highlight reel of reactions:

The sentiment

During the study, respondents recorded a quick asynchronous video message  – selfie-style, directly from their phones.

The automatic sentiment analysis showed that 52 percent of all statements were positive, 10 percent negative, and 38 percent neutral.

favorite mustard brands sentiments

The sentiment analysis pulls from what respondents said in their video responses.

The automatic theme explorer and Word Cloud gave me an idea of some of the most mentioned topics.

themes favorite mustard

At times, I also use the Theme Builder and my knowledge of the subject to build and group themes for topics that I consider related.

Wordcloud favorite mustard brands

The analysis

Next, I read through the transcripts of the responses. This is an easy way to read some more in-depth, skim ahead when applicable, and go back to previous answers in seconds.

Examples of what people said

“I don’t really have a favorite mustard brand. I just get the normal store-bought mustard. Nothing special. I just like yellow mustard. I feel like every yellow mustard is the same. Sometimes I get a spicy brown, but most of the time I get the store brand because I feel like they all taste the same,” said Josh, 33, of Port Clinton.

“I choose to use French’s as that is our favorite brand – it has a really tangy flavor. It is consistent, and it’s just got the perfect taste to add it to whatever we add our mustard to,” said Michelle, 43, of Glenolden.

“It makes all food tastes even better. That’s why French’s is my mustard. And I love the color – that classic yellow,” said Rennell, 59, of Los Angeles.

“So I have three different kinds. I have horseradish mustard. I use that for different types of sandwiches depending on the meat. Regular French’s, as well as a store brand yellow mustard. So for the regular yellow mustard, I use it for what is most common, like hot dogs, and burgers. Basically, the classics that call for the yellow mustard. Horseradish is more for artisan things, sandwiches, wraps, and whatnot. I would have to say my favorite is probably French’s just because it’s universal,” said Matt, 32, of Huntington Beach.

“So this is actually the mustard section in the fridge. Regular yellow, honey mustard; there is sweet and hot mustard; there is dijon mustard, horseradish mustard. It depends on what we’re eating,” said Louanne, 54, of Belchertown.

Mustard brands mentioned

Mustard brands that consumers had in their fridges during the study include in alphabetical order:

  • Best Choice yellow mustard
  • Bookbinders dijon mustard
  • Burman’s yellow mustard
  • Chestnut Hill yellow mustard
  • daiya hon’y mustard
  • Dijon mustard
  • Deli Market yellow mustard
  • Food Club dijon mustard
  • French’s honey mustard and yellow mustard
  • Great Value yellow mustard and honey mustard
  • Grey Poupon dijon mustard
  • Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard
  • Heinz yellow
  • Iowa Country dill mustard
  • Ken’s Steakhouse honey mustard
  • Kroger dijon mustard, spicy brown mustard, and yellow mustard
  • Maggie Mostaza (which respondent’s mom brings home from Ecuador)
  • Maille dijon originals
  • Market Pantry yellow mustard
  • Old Hawaii Recipies
  • Plochman’s Mild
  • Price Rite dijon mustard
  • Primal Kitchen organic dijon mustard
  • Publix spicy brown
  • Stoneground horseradish mustard
  • Trader Joe’s Dill Pickle and dijon mustard
  • Wegman’s yellow mustard
  • Whole Foods dijon mustard

Read next: [Consumer study] Is inflation already affecting holiday shopping?

“So my favorite mustard brand by far is classic yellow. It’s just classic; it’s delicious. I put it on everything. Ham and cheese sandwiches, hotdogs. I mean, I’ve just been using it for so long. That is just like a staple in my house, and it’s special for barbecues. I don’t know. It’s just everybody always wants the classic yellow,” said Stefanie, 40, of Secaucus.

Where to next?

We also heard from several consumers who said they didn’t have a favorite and just grab whatever mustard is available. That’s a potential opportunity for a follow-up:

  • Why do you think there’s no difference in the different products?
  • What are you looking for in mustard?
  • How could a specific brand rise above the rest?

Those might be questions for your next video surveys study.

Read next: How you can use video surveys for your next project!


What’s a question you’d like to ask consumers?